Ever since we became interested in politics, we have been arguing about
the same thing. Why do good plans not get implemented? Why do
they get implemented badly? And why do bad proposals win
through, simply because they find a majority?
This is not a side issue. It is what many people see, and their
frustration is to a good degree justified: it is aimed at real problems
and injustices for which politics often struggles to find solutions.
What rarely helps are the answers this frustration reaches for most
readily. Movements that promise simple solutions, or that blame the
problem on particular groups, seldom deliver what it would take to solve
problems for good. Better policy does not come from simpler
answers. It comes from better decisions.
Nor is it a problem of one side only. Deliberately targeting fast,
intuitive reflexes (ethos, pathos and identity in place of the
substance) is something we see right across the political spectrum,
including among those who claim to do better. The responsibility is
unevenly shared, but it does not lie with one camp alone. A solution
therefore starts by recognising this as a shared problem, not using it
as a weapon against the other side. Trust does not grow out of outrage.
It grows out of transparency and out of changes that people can
actually feel.
We searched for an approach for a long time and discarded many. With
Argupedia we believe we have found at least one building block. Why us
in particular? Because the problem sits at an interface, and we look at
it from two sides.
The founders
Aerospace engineering · Human factors
Julian Ohm
Studied aerospace engineering, then human factors engineering: the
discipline that examines how people decide under real conditions and
where they systematically fail. Alongside that, years of competitive
debating, as president of the Berlin Debating Union and through to
the final rounds of the German championship.
Cognitive science · Computer science
Paul Ohm
Studied cognitive science, then computer science and sport for
teaching. Founded a start-up that set out to bring learning content
into classrooms through gamification and digital tools. In other
words, the question of how to present knowledge so that people
actually take it in.
What connects us is this interface. Argupedia and the Global Debate
Evaluation Standard (GDES) behind it are our attempt to think together
questions that have long been answered individually but rarely in
combination. How do people think? How must information be presented so
that they can process it? How do you structure a debate so that it does
not overload people cognitively, yet stays transparent, verifiable and
comparable? We set out the reasoning behind this view in more detail in
the democratic imperative.
Two disciplines, one interface: engineering × UX, brought together in GDES.
At its core, this is an engineering and UX question: getting the
weighing-up out of people's heads and onto paper, where it can be
followed. Not because people lack judgement, but because nobody can do
this weighing-up in their head alone. We cannot either.