Four people of different ages and stations stand behind a translucent veil. One hand reaches through it and writes on a blank tablet, next to a balance scale at rest.

The justice framework

Every evaluation weighs things against each other: life against money, liberty against security, a burden on some against a benefit to others. This page sets out the standard used for that. It is the same for every debate.

bound to scoring/1.3 · as of 12 November 2026 · value choices are marked as settings

The test question

Which rules would someone agree to who does not know where in society they will end up?

Income, origin, talent, health and generation are unknown when the question is asked. What people need, that resources are scarce and how rules work remain known. The idea is John Rawls's and is called the veil of ignorance.

The question is impartial between persons. It is not neutral between theories of justice. Rawls himself rejects adding benefits and harms into one sum. Argupedia does add them, with more weight for those who have less. That is closer to John Harsanyi, who has people behind the same veil choose expected utility. For effort and luck the framework follows Ronald Dworkin: differences that come from a person's own effort may stand, differences that come from origin and chance justify little claim.

The test question is therefore a test and not a derivation. Every ranking and every weight on this page has to be able to pass it.

What the question assumes

  • Origin and talent are not merit.
  • What is compared is the wellbeing of those affected, converted to one common unit.
  • Those who have less count for more. How much more is a setting and is stated below.
  • Who stands behind the veil is a setting too: everyone a measure is responsible for, including future generations.

Two tiers

A standard with several principles needs a rule for conflicts. Here it has two tiers.

1 · The barrier

A harm is not netted against benefits when four conditions hold together: it is the means by which the measure works, it falls on identified persons, there is no way out, and it is existentially severe. Such a finding is shown next to the balance. The barrier is deliberately narrow so that it cannot be used to end every debate.

2 · The weighing

Everything else is weighed: how important the good is, how large the effect is and how well it is supported. The ranking of goods is not made case by case. It is fixed in advance in the value catalogue and the conversion anchors.

The principles

Six principles carry the standard. Each has a fixed place in the calculation.

Equal regard

A life counts the same, for every person and in every country.

Liberty and protection from arbitrary power

At the core of human dignity the barrier applies. Beyond it, basic rights carry a high weight, the right to vote included: whoever takes part in decisions helps shape their own life.

Basic needs secured

Food, housing and health weigh most where they are missing. The core of that protection also holds for people who are responsible for their own situation. The core includes housing and everything beyond a cut of 30 percent. More may be withheld only when someone turns down a specific reasonable job and can end the cut at any time.

Chances

Single decisions should not determine a whole life. Many are made under uncertainty and with unequal options.

Effort, within limits

Whoever contributes may expect part of the return. The claim is limited, and it is weaker where the return comes from chance, scarcity or inheritance.

Diminishing benefit

A euro helps more where money is short. Abundance is not protected the way need is.

Where justice sits in the calculation

Justice is not a single value in the catalogue. It sits in five places, and none of them may count the same reason twice.

  1. 1

    The barrier

    What is not netted.

    Place: before the calculation, as a finding next to the balance

  2. 2

    The ranking of goods

    Life and health at the top, basic rights, subsistence and education below, money in the middle, comfort at the bottom.

    Place: value weight V · Value catalogue

  3. 3

    The income weight

    The same euro weighs more at a low income than at a high one.

    Place: impact, per group · Baseline

  4. 4

    The claim by source of the money

    Money that was earned or agreed weighs more than a gain without any contribution, and a gain from the distress of others weighs least.

    Place: value weight V, one step per case

  5. 5

    Equal treatment

    Where one group in the same position carries more than another without a sound reason, that counts in addition: 10, 20 or 30 per cent of the amount shifted, by severity. A named standard is required, such as a constitutional court ruling.

    Place: an argument of its own next to the money

The income weight

The weight follows a fixed formula: the median income divided by the income of the group. A euro in the bottom fifth therefore counts several times a euro at the very top. The formula matches the assumption that each doubling of income brings the same additional benefit. That is a setting, not a measurement.

GroupWeight of one euro
Bottom fifth 2.5
Second fifth 1.5
Median 1.0
Fourth fifth 0.7
Top fifth 0.5
Top 10 per cent 0.4
Top 1 per cent 0.2
Public budgets 1.0
Companies 1.0

Where a basic need itself fails, what counts is no longer the money but the good: homelessness, health, life. That is the steep part of the curve.

Does the verdict hold?

How much low incomes count is a setting. Every debate is therefore calculated again with a flatter and a steeper weight. If a euro at a low income counts somewhat less or somewhat more than assumed, the verdict stays on the same side in 129 of 141 debates, and none turns from better to worse. If every euro counted the same wherever it lands, or low incomes counted twice as strongly, 37 debates would change side, 11 of them from better to worse or the other way round. Each debate page says in its section on robustness whether its verdict depends on this setting.

The claim by source of the money

Money normally counts with a value weight of 5. It is stepped down only in named cases, by two questions: how much did the recipient contribute to this amount? And is an emergency, the scarcity of a basic need or an addiction being exploited? The less the recipient contributed and the clearer the exploitation, the lower the step.

Kind of moneyVExamples
Earned, agreed or planned with5Wages, agreed rent, pension entitlements, the usual return on capital and risk, honestly earned profits where the other side gains too
Gain without a promise and without a contribution4Inheritance and gifts on the recipient's side, a future rent increase of the usual size that does not happen
Income without counter-value3Voluntary spending that is avoided
Scarcity or a poor decision is used2The part of a rent increase that runs ahead of wages and comes only from the state of the market; gambling operators' takings from freely chosen play
An emergency or a subsidy is deliberately skimmed1A tax cut that is kept as margin and not passed on
Income from addictiondoes not countThe share of gambling takings that comes from disordered play
Unlawful advantagedoes not countEvaded tax, proceeds of fraud, usury, rent that is already unlawful today

The lowest value for lawful conduct is 1, with one exception: income from addiction does not count. There is no step above 5. Where an exchange that benefits both sides no longer happens at all, value creation is lost; that counts as an argument of its own with the higher value weight of prosperity and production. No single evaluation decides whether an income is deserved: ordinary profits and high incomes do not fall under the rule. Effort and talent cannot be separated; the source of the money is a rough substitute.

Who counts

Future generations

An effect does not shrink because it comes later. A life year thirty years from now counts like one today. Nothing is discounted for time.

People in other countries

The worth of a person is the same everywhere. What is graded is responsibility. For people in another state, their own society is responsible first. What a measure itself causes counts in full, wherever it occurs.

SituationResponsibility
Caused by the measure, at home or abroadfull
People under the state's jurisdiction, including those seeking protectionfull
Emergency aid where the home state cannot cope alonehigh, not yet quantified
Other aid to people in other stateslow, not yet quantified

The grading is its own step in the calculation and never part of the value weight. The two open rates will be set with the first debate on development aid.

The exchange rates

The weight of a good follows from its conversion anchor and its value weight together. That yields fixed exchange rates. The table shows how much of a good weighs as much as one life year. The test question can be put to it: someone who does not know who they are would have to be able to accept these rates.

GoodVOne life year weighs as much as
Deprivation of liberty91.1 years
Homelessness83.9 years
A vote in a national election944 votes
Lived time96,500 hours
Climate damage7571 tonnes of CO₂
Money in the bottom fifth532,000 €
Money at the median580,000 €
Money in the top 10 per cent5200,000 €

V is the value weight of the class; single arguments may deviate by 1 with a stated reason. The anchors are on the baseline page.

What is open

The framework is not finished. These points are named and not yet decided.

  • The rates for emergency aid and other aid abroad.
  • Step 2 and “does not count” for income from addiction are decided, but not yet applied in the debates on rents and gambling. They apply from the next version of each evaluation.

Ask the bot

The bot explains the method and the debate on this page. It answers only from Argupedia's content and does no research of its own.

Before you ask

  • The answers are written by an AI model (Claude Haiku by Anthropic). They may be wrong or incomplete. The content of the pages is authoritative.
  • The bot gives no legal, financial, medical or voting advice.
  • What you type is sent to Anthropic in the USA. Do not enter names, contact details or other personal information.

The terms of use (section 9a) and the privacy notice for the chat apply.