Argupedia Baseline

A speed limit saves tonnes. A hospital reform saves lives. A tax reform moves euros. For these things to be comparable at all, they are converted into one common quantity. This page sets out the factors used for that conversion and where each one comes from.

argupedia-baseline/1.0 · as of 31 October 2026 · bound to scoring/1.3 · result: Normalised Impact (unitless)

How a quantity becomes a score

Four steps, three questions. The Baseline is responsible for the first: how much? After that, the value catalogue (how important?) and the evidence rules (how certain?) take over.

  1. 1

    Raw quantity

    The effect in its own real-world unit: tonnes, deaths, hours, euros.

    1.4 million t CO₂ a year

  2. × anchor
  3. 2

    Onto the common scale

    Converted through one of the anchors below. From here on everything can be added up: tonnes next to life years next to euros.

    × €100/t

  4. × w × c
  5. 3

    Normalised Impact I

    Weighted by whose money it is (w) and whether anyone notices it at all (c).

    × 1.0 × 1.0 = I 0.14

  6. × V × P
  7. 4

    Argument score

    Multiplied by value weight and plausibility. Only this step lies outside the Baseline.

    × 7 × 8.5 / 10 = 0.83

The example is real: it is the CO₂ argument of the measure “Tempolimit 130”, a 130 km/h speed limit on German motorways, a debate on the German side of Argupedia.

Which quantity counts: the expected one

Step 1 asks for the effect in its own real-world unit, and in the amount that actually occurs on average. If a harm occurs in only one case in ten, the calculation does not take ten units and then a discount on certainty; it takes one. A harm that rarely occurs is a smaller harm, not a large one with a small probability.

That sets the order: first derive the quantity, then set the plausibility. P is not a dial for the quantity. Leaving the large number in place and lowering P instead gives the same score, because the product is the same. But what is stored and shown is then a quantity that does not exist: as the impact figure on every argument card, and as the yardstick against which arguments are compared across measures and areas. The score is right; the display is wrong.

There is one exception: when the quantity is not Argupedia's own. Where the analysis judges someone else's number instead of deriving its own (a party's promise, a quoted demand), the quantity used is the claimed one, and plausibility may correct it. The argument then also stores where the number comes from and why it was not derived anew. It does not enter the comparisons of the size distribution; otherwise the scale would measure a claim against a set of the analysis's own derivations.

Read the other way round, the rule is a test. A low plausibility has three possible reasons. A finding speaks against the effect. Or nothing supports it: no study, no precedent, no complete chain of effects. Or the quantity was never derived. The first two are covered on the plausibility page; the third is a construction error, and the answer to it is a better number, not a wider range.

The anchors compared by size

19 anchors across six orders of magnitude. The scale is logarithmic; on a linear scale nothing but the statistical life would be visible. Each point shows the amount with which one unit of the thing goes onto the common scale.

set independently derived: depends on another anchor

Not on this scale: what a working life earns

These anchors are real money, not a valuation. They state what a person earns on average over their working life and how better skills change that; they are used where a measure changes later earnings. They cannot be compared with the values above: what a life weighs is in the life-year anchor and is the same for every person, including someone who never works.

What balances what

This is the whole purpose of normalising: making quantities without a common unit convertible into one another. Measured against one statistical life, the following count the same:

14,000
t CO₂e
CO₂ equivalent
132,701
vehicle hour of travel time
Vehicle hour
35.0
life year (QALY)
Life year
1,400,000
€
Euro at face value

These ratios are not an opinion on the value of a life; the moral weight is carried elsewhere, by the value weight V. They only say which quantities weigh the same in the calculation.

What the anchors depend on

The 21 anchors are not 21 decisions. 11 are set independently, 10 are derived, and 8 other values depend on the life year alone. Whoever moves that one number moves a large part of the tree.

Life year €40,000 set independently
Statistical life €1.40 million 35 life years × €40,000
Serious injury €120,000 3 life years × €40,000
Minor injury €6,000 0.15 life years × €40,000
Person hour €6.85 €40,000 ÷ 5,840 waking hours a year (16 h a day)
Retirement year €12,000 about 1,750 working hours a year (35 hours a week × 50 weeks) at the full value of the waking hour of €6.85, which is 30 percent of a life year
Deprivation of liberty €40,000 5,840 waking hours a year × €6.85 (forced time without anything in return) = €40,004
Vehicle hour €10.55 business share × working hour × travel time factor 0.8 × 1.1 + (1 − business share) × person hour × 1.60; at a 20 percent business share and 30 percent of the waking hour (€2.05) ⇒ €10.55
Life satisfaction €5,700 One healthy life year corresponds to 7 points of life satisfaction for one year: €40,000 ÷ 7 = €5,714, rounded to €5,700
CO₂ equivalent €100 set independently
Nitrogen oxides €15,400 set independently
Working hour €45 set independently
Forced procedure €50 Working hour (€45) as the floor, plus a surcharge for compulsion and physical intervention
Working hour (USA) €41.90 set independently
Doctor's hour €95 set independently
Basic housing need €3,700 set independently
Homelessness €12,700 set independently
Euro at face value €1 set independently
Lifetime earnings €1.50 million set independently
Skills advantage €352,500 23.5 percent higher earnings per standard deviation × €1.5 million lifetime earnings
Vote €1,000 set independently

The two weights

Anchors convert quantities into euros, in a straight line. The two layers above them are not linear. For 91 percent of all scored arguments they decide more about the result than any physical anchor, because nine in ten arguments are money flows.

Income weight w

Whose money is it?

0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 Q1 Q2 median Q4 Q5 top10 top1 Income relative to the median →

A euro for the poorest fifth weighs 2.5 times as much as for the median.

w = (y_median / y_band)^η, η = 1.0

Perceptibility weight c

Does anyone notice it at all?

0.3 0.5 1.0 0.1% 1% Effect per head, share of income →

An effect that stays below 0.1 percent of income per head counts only at 30 percent.

c = 0.3 at a share ≤ 0.1%, linear up to c = 1.0 from 1%

Every anchor in detail

Value, source, derivation, and the places where the approach departs from the source value. The change history of every anchor is open: an evaluation from yesterday must stay traceable, even if the factor is set differently today.

Some anchors are one number, some a range. An hour in a waiting room does not weigh as much as an hour in the car, and a working hour is something else again. Denying such differences does not make the evaluation more precise, only less honest. Where a range is given, a debate may choose within it; it has to justify the choice, and the justification is stored with it.

Life & health

What a life year, a life, a healthy year weighs on the common scale. This is where the Baseline's only normative root setting sits.

Life year

per life year (QALY)

€40,000 applies everywhere

The root of the whole Baseline. One additional year of life in full health counts €40,000. Two further anchors, the value of a life and every time value, are derived from it rather than set independently. Whoever moves this number moves all of them.

No rangeNo range. This value is the root: a life year weighs the same in every debate, otherwise the result would depend on who writes the evaluation.

Approach ≠ source value Upper end of NICE's standard range of £25,000 to £35,000 per QALY (raised in April 2026, previously £20,000 to £30,000), converted at a rate of about 1.15. The value used is a rounded €40,000.

A politically set willingness-to-pay threshold, expressly NOT the empirically estimated opportunity cost of the health system (Claxton 2015: about £13,000). Count once: the moral weight is already carried by V = 10; this anchor carries only the quantity.

17 arguments use this anchor, in 12 proposals · 12 of them checked

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 4 July 2026 €40,000 current

    Introduced with the first registry and unchanged since. The rise of the NICE range in April 2026 was checked and does not change the rounded value.

    grundanker/1.2

Statistical life

per death avoided

€1.40 million applies everywhere

One avoided death counts €1.4 million. The number is not a setting of its own: it is the life-year anchor multiplied by an assumed remaining life expectancy of 35 years.

No rangeUse only when the remaining life expectancy is unknown. When it is known (older people in heat waves and air pollution, newborns in perinatal mortality), calculate through the life-year anchor: quantity = cases × years. The flat 35 years is the fallback, not the rule.

Derivation 35 life years × €40,000

International willingness-to-pay studies and the risk value of Germany's Federal Transport Infrastructure Plan are higher (€3 to 7 million). These outside values are deliberately not adopted case by case: raising the anchor would be a registry decision and would carry every life, QALY and time argument with it. SURCHARGE FOR RELATIVES (since 3 September 2026, conv/angehoerige-zuschlag/1.0): the anchor counts only the victim. The suffering of family and friends is added as a separate item, 10 percent of the cases at the same anchor (quantity = 0.1 × cases, "suffering of relatives"). Calibrated on the NICE exception (family QALY at 9 percent of a child's loss) and the two-part definition of human costs in the 2019 EU handbook.

12 arguments use this anchor, in 9 proposals · 8 of them checked

Change history 3 entries
  1. since 3 September 2026 €1.40 million current

    Value unchanged; a 10 percent surcharge for relatives introduced as a separate item (tempolimit-130 v4). Existing evaluations adopt it at their next review.

    scoring/1.3

  2. since 25 August 2026 €1.40 million

    Value unchanged, but fixed as binding for all debates after one evaluation had used a different value.

    scoring/1.3 · 872c4439

  3. since 4 July 2026 €1.40 million

    Introduced with the first registry, derived from the life-year anchor.

    grundanker/1.2

Serious injury

per seriously injured person

€120,000 applies everywhere

The health loss of one seriously injured person, expressed in life years. It closes the largest gap in the stock: deaths had a price, injuries did not, although they are part of the impact in almost every accident argument.

Range €80,000 – €200,000

€120,000 as the rule. Closer to €200,000 (5 life years) where the group really is MAIS 3+: motorway and high-speed crashes, workplace accidents with lasting effects. Closer to €80,000 (2 life years) where police counts dominate and many cases leave no lasting harm after a short hospital stay.

Derivation 3 life years × €40,000

Health loss only. Treatment, rehabilitation, lost earnings and property damage are a separate item and are booked as money. The official accident cost rates of €120,000 to €149,000 per seriously injured person are exactly such resource costs and must not be added here. That they happen to be of the same order as this anchor is a trap: booking both counts twice. SURCHARGE FOR RELATIVES (since 3 September 2026, conv/angehoerige-zuschlag/1.0): the anchor counts only the victim. The suffering of family and friends is added as a separate item, 10 percent of the cases at the same anchor (quantity = 0.1 × cases, "suffering of relatives"). Calibrated on the NICE exception (family QALY at 9 percent of a child's loss) and the two-part definition of human costs in the 2019 EU handbook.

1 argument uses this anchor, in 1 proposal · checked

Change history 2 entries
  1. since 3 September 2026 €120,000 current

    Value unchanged; a 10 percent surcharge for relatives introduced as a separate item (tempolimit-130 v4). Existing evaluations adopt it at their next review.

    scoring/1.3

  2. since 30 August 2026 €120,000

    Newly added. Injury effects were part of the impact in every accident and health argument, but no justification expressed them in life years; that was the most common reason for arguments being only partly wired. The value triangulates two independent lines: the MAIS shares of the EU handbook, scaled down to the broader German police definition, and the values implicitly used in the stock.

    scoring/1.3

Minor injury

per slightly injured person

€6,000 applies everywhere

The health loss of one slightly injured person. Small per case, but in transport arguments minor injuries occur ten to twenty times as often as serious ones.

Range €2,000 – €20,000

€6,000 as the rule. Closer to €20,000 where a noticeable share reaches MAIS 2. Closer to €2,000 for trivial injuries only.

Derivation 0.15 life years × €40,000

Same separation as for serious injuries: health loss only, resource costs kept apart.

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 30 August 2026 €6,000 current

    Newly added. Injury effects were part of the impact in every accident and health argument, but no justification expressed them in life years; that was the most common reason for arguments being only partly wired. The value triangulates two independent lines: the MAIS shares of the EU handbook, scaled down to the broader German police definition, and the values implicitly used in the stock.

    scoring/1.3

Life satisfaction

per 1 point of life satisfaction (scale 0–10) for one person for one year

€5,700 applies everywhere

What it is worth to be one point more satisfied for a year, on the 0 to 10 scale used by surveys such as the German Socio-Economic Panel. This makes it possible to value burdens that are neither illness nor money: worry about one's job, the burden of unemployment beyond income, separation from family. Derived from the life year so that satisfaction and health sit on the same scale.

Derivation One healthy life year corresponds to 7 points of life satisfaction for one year: €40,000 ÷ 7 = €5,714, rounded to €5,700

Approach ≠ source value The UK government sets life satisfaction at 8 for a year without health problems and at 1 for the point at which a life weighs as much as death; 7 points lie between the two. Its own money value per point (£13,000, about 0.42 of average earnings) would be roughly double; the platform takes only the bridge, not the British amount.

Only for documented satisfaction effects at the same income; where income moves too, it stands as a separate money item. Never calculate through income compensation (what a survey reports as "as much as X euros more income"): it inflates values two to six times. Count once: never next to a health item for the same loss.

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 24 September 2026 €5,700 current

    Newly added (Julian, 24 September 2026). Carries the rules on insecurity (fixed-term contracts: 0.21 points = €1,200), jobs (the non-monetary burden of unemployment) and family separation (life satisfaction of refugees with relatives abroad). Until then each record set such burdens freely, for example "a tenth of a net income".

    scoring/1.3

Climate & environment

The damage costs of physical environmental effects. Damage costs, not prices: an allowance price is a money flow, never the valuation of the damage.

CO₂ equivalent

per t CO₂e

€100 applies everywhere

What it costs to avoid one tonne of CO₂ equivalent. Deliberately abatement cost and not damage cost: the life anchor measures what avoiding a health loss is worth, not what the loss does, and two anchors in one evaluation have to ask the same question.

Range €45 – €200

€100/t as the rule, also under an emissions cap. Since 31 October 2026 a binding cap (EU ETS, RGGI, California) acts on the QUANTITY, not the rate: only the share of displaced tonnes that really lowers total emissions is booked (rule klimanutzen-ets/1.0). Lowering the rate towards €45 as well would count the cap twice. Closer to €200 where abatement is expensive and no cheaper alternative exists, such as heating buildings or industrial processes. The rate applies in both directions: an avoided tonne and an additional tonne weigh the same.

Approach ≠ source value The UBA recommends DAMAGE costs of €345/t at a 1 percent rate of pure time preference and €990/t at 0 percent. These numbers are not wrong; they answer a different question from the life anchor. Argupedia therefore uses abatement costs, not damage costs.

One fixed rate, deliberately not graded by year of emission: the chosen evaluation period must not decide what a tonne weighs. As a money flow it forces the perceptibility weight to c = 1.0. The switch from €350 to €100/t does not say that climate damage is smaller than thought; it makes both anchors answer the same kind of question.

5 arguments use this anchor, in 3 proposals · 1 of them checked

Change history 3 entries
  1. since 26 August 2026 €100 current

    Switched from damage costs (€350/t) to abatement costs (€100/t). The occasion was a coherence check against the life anchor: together they implied that one human life equals 4,000 t of CO₂, against 13,800 t on EU values, 38,000 t on the literature average and 60,000 t on EPA values. The cause was not the UBA number but the mix of two bases: a budget shadow price for life, damage costs for climate. Both now rest on a shadow price, and the ratio is 14,000 t per life. The old conversion stays in the registry.

    scoring/1.3

  2. since 25 August 2026 €350

    Traced back to the UBA cost rate and fixed as binding for all debates (€345 at 2025 prices per tonne at a 1 percent rate of pure time preference, rounded). The occasion was one evaluation that had used a different rate.

    scoring/1.3 · 872c4439

  3. since 10 July 2026 €200

    Registry default when Scoring v1.3 was introduced; not backed by a source and never applied to an argument in the stock.

    scoring/1.3 · 59d5de50

Nitrogen oxides

per t NOₓ

€15,400 applies everywhere

The health, ecosystem and crop damage that one tonne of nitrogen oxides from exhaust pipes causes. Unlike CO₂, damage cost and not abatement cost: air pollutants have no market price for abatement, and the health share of the rate itself rests on the value of a life year.

Range €8,000 – €30,000

€15,400 per tonne as the rule, the transport average across all roads. Closer to €30,000 for emissions mainly in built-up areas (buses, delivery traffic, city streets), closer to €8,000 on motorways and in rural areas.

As a money flow anchored in damage costs, the rate forces c = 1.0. Particulate matter has no anchor of its own: for combustion against battery vehicles the direction cannot be determined, because heavier vehicles wear more tyre and brake material.

1 argument uses this anchor, in 1 proposal · checked

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 4 September 2026 €15,400 current

    Newly added while adding the calculation to flottengrenzwerte-2035: con-5 (more nitrogen oxides) used the UBA rate but could not be wired without an anchor. Transport average of the Methodological Convention, rounded.

    scoring/1.3

Time

Time gained and lost. Fully derived from the life-year anchor rather than imported; otherwise the same hour would be valued differently depending on where the number came from.

Person hour

per hour of personal time

€6.85 applies everywhere

A person's time, derived from their life year rather than from an imported time cost rate. The only anchor with a true range: one hour is not like another, and the difference can be justified. Hence a range with a selection rule rather than one number that fits everywhere equally badly.

Range €2.05 – €6.85

The less the hour leaves room for anything else, the closer to the upper end. €6.85, the full value of a waking hour, for forced time without anything in return that is tiresome but does not touch body or freedom of movement: waiting rooms, visits to public offices, applications, proof and reporting duties, a doctor's visit for a certificate, returning deposit bottles without a choice, a traffic jam behind a full road closure (since 31 October 2026, rule erzwungene-zeit/1.1, even when the duty is ordered). Real interventions such as a military medical examination, an ordered examination or being held go through the forced procedure. €3.42, half a waking hour, for time with something else going on: accompanying someone, waiting while busy. €2.05, 30 percent of the waking hour, for freely chosen travel time in one's own vehicle, the usual case in transport: whoever drives can phone, listen and think; what is lost is not the hour but its remainder. Anything in between may be chosen, but never without a reason. Sleep does not count at all; it is already left out of the 5,840 hours. Private time flows go through the value catalogue entry "Lifetime" (V 9) without a perceptibility weight (c = 1); working time is money and goes through the working hour.

Derivation €40,000 ÷ 5,840 waking hours a year (16 h a day)

Scale-invariant: if the life-year anchor rises, the whole range rises with it. The factor of 0.3 for travel time is derived three independent ways: the ratio of time value to wage for private trips of 0.25 to 0.5 (Wardman, Small; Ehreke et al. 2015: €4.87/h for commuting by car), Kahneman's day reconstruction (commuting 2.1 against a daily average of 2.9) and an ideal commute above zero for 99 percent of respondents (Redmond and Mokhtarian 2001). Count once: the factor is the quality of the hour, V 9 is lifetime one step below life; never two of them for the same idea. No perceptibility weight on lifetime: a few lost minutes per trip are felt, and c is kept for money flows. Other calculations value private time like working time at wage rates (€21 to €49/h) and are therefore higher; here it counts as lifetime, on the same yardstick as accident victims.

6 arguments use this anchor, in 6 proposals · 5 of them checked

Change history 5 entries
  1. since 31 October 2026 €6.85 current

    Selection rule sharpened (Julian, 31 October 2026, second round; rule erzwungene-zeit/1.1): tiresome compulsory time such as applications, proof, reporting duties, a doctor's visit, returning deposit bottles or visits to public offices counts at €6.85, even when it is ordered; the military medical examination was taken off the list because it is an intervention. Value and range unchanged.

    scoring/1.3

  2. since 3 September 2026 €6.85

    Perceptibility weight c on lifetime withdrawn (c = 1) on the same day: with c 0.3 on the 30 percent share, 9 percent of a life hour would have remained, and one human life would have weighed 2.5 million travel hours, beyond any comparison figure. The life-year balance (4,230 lost against 4,730 gained) would not have been visible in the score. Lost minutes per trip are felt; c is an instrument for money in very small amounts.

    scoring/1.3

  3. since 3 September 2026 €6.85

    Floor of the range lowered from €3.42 to €2.05: travel time in one's own vehicle loses 30 rather than 50 percent of the waking hour. Half a waking hour implied that an hour in the car weighs like a serious illness; time value research, day reconstruction and the ideal commute point to a utility of 0.7. Count once was reordered at the same time: travel time is lifetime (value catalogue `lebenszeit`, V 9) and carries the perceptibility weight c; until then it had V 4 and c = 1, so the anchor factor and the value class carried the same discount twice. Occasion: tempolimit-130 v4.

    scoring/1.3

  4. since 26 August 2026 €6.85

    Combined into the "person hour" with a range of €3.42 to €6.85. The occasion: the stock used five different hourly values (€5, 6, 10, 12, 20), because there was no anchor for personal time at all, only for vehicle hours. A range with a selection rule shows what really differs instead of forcing an equality that does not exist.

    scoring/1.3

  5. since 25 August 2026 €6.85

    Introduced as the "waking hour" with conv/zeit-welfare/1.0 to replace the placeholder time_value.

    scoring/1.3 · fd89f2d1

Retirement year

per year moved from retirement into working life

€12,000 applies everywhere

What it costs when a year moves from retirement into working life. What is lost is not the whole year but the working time in it: evenings, weekends and holidays stay free. So the roughly 1,750 working hours of a year are counted at the full value of the waking hour, 30 percent of a life year.

Range €8,000 – €20,000

€12,000 as the rule. Closer to €20,000 for physically demanding jobs or poor health, where the extra working year also eats into the free hours. Closer to €8,000 for a gradual move into part-time work. Never book together with the net income from the same working time: the value already is the net loss; taxes and contributions on the extra pay are a separate item.

Derivation about 1,750 working hours a year (35 hours a week × 50 weeks) at the full value of the waking hour of €6.85, which is 30 percent of a life year

Until 19 September 2026 the anchor stood at €20,000: all 5,840 waking hours of a year at half the rate, so half a life year. That also counted the hours a working person has free anyway. The choice of pension deductions at retirement points to €12,000 to €28,000 a year, but it only measures those who actually buy the earlier exit, the people to whom it is worth the most. For the average person affected the value is lower, so the standard value sits at the lower end of this measurement.

Change history 2 entries
  1. since 20 September 2026 €12,000 current

    Julian's decision of 19 September 2026 (leaning that way since 5 September): half a life year is too much. Whoever works one year longer loses that year's working time, not their evenings, weekends and holidays. New: about 1,750 working hours at the full value of the waking hour, €12,000 or 30 percent of a life year. Affected: rentenalter-kopplung (con-1, con-3, new version) and the newly adopted record rente-mit-63-streichen.

    scoring/1.3

  2. since 26 August 2026 €20,000

    Newly added. The value had stood only in rentenalter-kopplung con-1, one of the largest arguments in the stock (i = 3.6), as a one-off setting without registry cover. The review showed it can be derived two ways: as a full year of waking hours at the bound person-hour rate and as half a life year, with the same result, independently supported by the deductions new pensioners accept.

    scoring/1.3

Deprivation of liberty

per year in prison, immigration detention or forced labour

€40,000 applies everywhere

What a year weighs in which a person has no control over their time. Derived from the person hour, not from a compensation law: whoever is locked up loses every waking hour at the full rate, so the year weighs as much as a life year. The two laws that put a price on it are just below and just above.

Range €27,375 – €43,100

€40,000 as the rule: complete deprivation against one's will and through no fault of one's own, such as immigration detention, forced labour or wrongful imprisonment. Every waking hour of the year is then forced time without anything in return. The more voluntary or incomplete the deprivation, the closer to the lower end: open prison, house arrest, confinement to barracks with leave, a stay someone preferred to a worse alternative. The lower end, €27,375, is the German compensation rate for wrongful imprisonment (€75 per day or part of a day); the upper end, €43,100, is the American one ($50,000 a year). Anything in between may be chosen, but never without a reason.

Derivation 5,840 waking hours a year × €6.85 (forced time without anything in return) = €40,004

Approach ≠ source value €75 × 365 = €27,375 a year. The rate is fixed in nominal terms and does not grow with prices: until 7 October 2020 it was €25; the tripling followed a 2017 resolution of the conference of justice ministers, which called €25 "too low". Adjusted for inflation since 2020 it would be about €93 a day or €34,000 a year today. USA: 28 U.S.C. § 2513, $50,000 a year, about €43,100. Austria: €20 to €50 a day.

Count once: the anchor REPLACES the person hour for the same hours, never both. Violence, illness and death in detention or forced labour are not included; they go as a separate item through the life-year anchor, never as a higher rate. Accommodation costs are money and sit on the cost side. Scale-invariant: if the life-year anchor rises, this value rises with it.

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 20 September 2026 €40,000 current

    Newly added (Julian, 20 September 2026). The same good stood in the stock at €20,000 (plattformhaftung-betrugswerbung: half a life year per year of forced labour), €40,000 (zurueckweisungen-grenze: a quarter year of forced waking time = €10,000) and €43,000 (detention-removal-buildout, global-forced-labour-tariffs: the US compensation rate). Checked and rejected: the German compensation rate as the value (€27,375); it is fixed in nominal terms and would be about €34,000 adjusted for inflation. Julian: the two are not far apart, and the derivation holds. The range reflects how voluntary or involuntary the deprivation was.

    scoring/1.3

Working hour

per hour worked

€45 Germany only

Paid work that is lost or tied up. Deliberately NOT derived from the life year: what counts here is the economic effect, not the value of lifetime. That makes it the only time anchor with its own empirical source and the only one that depends on the country.

Range €34.90 – €45

€45.00 for working time in Germany. €34.90, the EU average, when the work is done elsewhere in Europe. The value measures what working time COSTS, not what it is worth to the worker; for that, the person hour applies. Never both on the same item.

Approach ≠ source value Industry and services, 2025. The EU average is €34.90; employers in Germany pay about 29 percent more.

Watch for double counting: an hour booked as lost work must not also be booked as lost lifetime. The vehicle hour already mixes both; the work share is included there.

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 26 August 2026 €45 current

    Newly added. The stock needed the economic value of time (military medical examination, lost work, tied-up operating time) but only had lifetime anchors, hence ad hoc rates between €10 and €20/h.

    scoring/1.3

Working hour (USA)

per hour worked

€41.90 USA only

Paid work that is lost or tied up in the United States: the counterpart of the German working hour, with the same definition (employer cost per hour worked) from US data. Applies only in US records.

Range €40.40 – €44.20

€41.90 for US private-sector working time (BLS ECEC, $46.89 per hour worked, June 2026, at the October average of $1.1202/€). €44.20 for work in the public sector or mixed (all civilian workers $49.46). €40.40 when the record uses a rate of $1.16/€. As in Germany, the value measures what working time COSTS, not what it is worth to the worker; for that, the global person hour applies. Never both on the same item.

Approach ≠ source value Private industry, June 2026: wages $32.82 (70.0 percent), benefits $14.07; all civilian workers $49.46, state and local government $66.45.

Watch for double counting, as with the German working hour. The person hour (€6.85) applies unchanged in the United States: it is derived from the life year, a value setting, and not from wages.

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 31 October 2026 €41.90 current

    Newly added (Julian, 31 October 2026, second round; rule anker-jurisdiktion/1.1): US records had so far valued working time at the German €45 or at their own settings.

    scoring/1.3

Doctor's hour

per hour of a doctor's work in a practice

€95 Germany only

What an hour of a doctor's work in outpatient care costs: the annual surplus per practice owner, spread over the owner's hours. The working hour of €45 is the average of all employees; valuing the scarcest resource of the outpatient system at the average rate would understate what every displaced consultation costs.

Range €70 – €150

€95 for a practice's doctor minutes as the rule, the surplus per owner hour. €70 when calculating without deductions for holidays, training and sickness; €150 for specialist practices with a high surplus or where revenue per hour measures the scarce resource. Doctor's time only: reception, medical assistants and administration go through the working hour × 0.8 = €36. Never next to the payment for the same consultations; that would be the same hour twice.

Approach ≠ source value €190,400 ÷ 2,000 owner hours (50 hours a week × 40 working weeks) = €95 per hour. Surplus after staff, premises and material costs, before the owner's taxes and pension provision.

Business view, money, V 5 (enforcement costs/business budgets), c = 1. The patients' time in the same consultations is lifetime (person hour) and goes in a separate argument, never both in one.

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 5 September 2026 €95 current

    Newly added while adding the calculation to au-pflicht-tag-1 (con-1): the rule for working time valued the doctor's minute at €36, less than an average working hour. Julian's decision of 5 September 2026: surplus per owner hour from the Zi Practice Panel, €95.

    scoring/1.3

Forced procedure

per hour of an ordered procedure

€50 applies everywhere

Time that the state demands of a person and that cannot be avoided. The only time anchor where the hour carries not only an opportunity cost but an aversion of its own: an unwanted examination in which one is tested and classified is more than lost time.

Range €45 – €50

Only for real interventions in the body or freedom of movement that cannot be avoided: military medical examination, ordered physical examination, taking blood, examination of the body by an expert, police identification processing, body search, being held, custody or being brought before an authority for hours, at €50. Close to €45 (the working hour as the floor) where the intervention is slight (a short appearance without examination). Tiresome compulsory time without an intervention, such as applications, proof, reporting duties, a summons to a hearing, a doctor's visit for a certificate or returning deposit bottles, is not a procedure and counts at the person hour of €6.85 (since 31 October 2026; the former middle level of €20 to €30 no longer applies). The test: if the hour could be done just as well without physical access or being held (in writing, online, with a break), it is tiresome, not an intervention. Longer deprivation of liberty over days to years goes through freiheitsentzug-jahr, never through these hours.

Derivation Working hour (€45) as the floor, plus a surcharge for compulsion and physical intervention

COUNT ONCE, especially easy to break here: the surcharge for the intervention is already in this rate. An argument that uses it must not also raise its value weight V to the fundamental-rights level; otherwise the same compulsion counts twice, once in the quantity and once in the weight. And the anchor prices only the procedure: whoever is then actually called up, convicted or obliged is a separate item with a separate argument.

Change history 3 entries
  1. since 31 October 2026 €50 current

    Boundary decided (Julian, 31 October 2026, second round; rule erzwungene-zeit/1.1): the anchor applies only to real interventions; tiresome compulsory time counts at the person hour of €6.85. Range from €20–50 to €45–50/h, because the middle level for administrative time no longer applies. Value unchanged.

    scoring/1.3

  2. since 31 October 2026 €50

    Scope extended from Germany to global (Julian, 31 October 2026; rule erzwungene-zeit/1.0): forced time is valued the same in German and US records. The surcharge for compulsion is a value setting; the German working hour only supplies the derivation of the floor. Value and range unchanged.

    scoring/1.3

  3. since 30 August 2026 €50

    Newly added. The stock had no anchor for forced state procedures and made do with ad hoc rates (neuer-wehrdienst: €20/h). The person hour does not fit, because it measures only the value of free or tied-up time, not the fact that the time takes place against one's will and on one's own body.

    scoring/1.3

Vehicle hour

per vehicle hour of travel time

€10.55 Germany only

The value transport arguments work with: one hour a vehicle is on the road with its occupants. Country-dependent because it depends on the share of business trips and on labour costs. It is also the only time anchor with two rates, because a chosen hour of travel and an imposed hour are not the same good.

Range €9.50 – €20

TRANSITIONAL ANCHOR. New evaluations no longer book travel time per vehicle but in two items: private person hours as lifetime (person hour €2.05, forced €6.85, V 9, c = 1) and business person hours as money (working hour × 0.8 = €36, V 5). Where the vehicle hour still stands: €10.55 for freely chosen travel time, as the rule on trunk roads; €15.30 for forced time (full waking hour); closer to €9.50 where the business share is low and more people sit in the car. The surcharge for compulsion is IN THE RATE.

Derivation business share × working hour × travel time factor 0.8 × 1.1 + (1 − business share) × person hour × 1.60; at a 20 percent business share and 30 percent of the waking hour (€2.05) ⇒ €10.55

Approach ≠ source value MiD 2023 shows 19 percent of passenger kilometres as "business"; 86 percent of these trips are regular work trips (tradespeople, couriers, care, average 10 km). Only the classic business trip (average 32 km) uses the motorway; weighted by motorway use that is 20 percent. Commuting does NOT count; it is unpaid personal time.

Deliberately derived rather than imported: the Federal Transport Infrastructure Plan values a life year at about €38,000 through its risk value, but at €74,000 to €102,000 through its private time cost rate. Adopting the time rate would import that break. Cross-check for the business part: €45 × 0.8 = €36 per person hour matches the updated plan rate for commercial passenger transport (€29.48 gross wages in 2021 ⇒ about €35 in 2025). The anchor mixes lifetime and money in one number, and that is exactly why it is only transitional: the mix forced an averaged V (4) that undervalued lifetime and overvalued working time.

Change history 3 entries
  1. since 3 September 2026 €10.55 current

    From €12.30 to €10.55 (travel time at 30 rather than 50 percent of the waking hour) and declared a transitional anchor: evaluations separate lifetime (V 9, c) and working time (money, V 5). Records still using the vehicle hour: berlin-poller-stopp, berlin-tempo30-schulwege, to be switched at the next review.

    scoring/1.3

  2. since 1 September 2026 €12.30

    Revised from €17.00 to €12.30 and given a second rate for forced time (€16.70). Three findings from the re-evaluation of tempolimit-130: the €17 silently assumed a 25 percent business share, while the anchor's own formula gave about €15 as the rule. The business share can be derived from MiD 2023 and is 20 percent (classic business trips only; commuting is not working time, and tradespeople and couriers do not use the motorway). The occupancy of non-business trunk-road trips is 1.60 rather than 1.80, because commuters with an occupancy of 1.1 account for a good quarter of motorway mileage. In addition, the travel time factor of 0.8 delivers on a reservation that had so far only been noted as an unused floor of the range.

    scoring/1.3

  3. since 25 August 2026 €17

    Introduced with conv/zeit-welfare/1.0, together with the re-evaluation of tempolimit-130; replaces the placeholder time_value.

    scoring/1.3 · fd89f2d1

Housing

Housing as a good in kind, in three levels: the basic need (what social law recognises as adequate, graded by region), avoided homelessness (considerably more, because the way back is hard), and everything above that at the market price through face value.

Basic housing need

per person-year without adequate housing

€3,700 Germany only

What an adequate roof over one's head weighs per person and year, the part of housing that is a basic need. Measured by what society is permanently willing to pay so that someone is adequately housed: the adequacy limits of social law, graded by region. Anything above that (the larger, better, better-suited flat) is a legitimate wish but not a basic need, and counts at the market price with the ordinary consumption weight.

Range €2,600 – €5,400

€3,700 per person and year as the rule: what social law recognises as an adequate gross rent excluding heating, the housing benefit maximum for a two-person household in rent level IV, €619 a month, €3,714 per person. Regional rather than national average: for a state or city debate the guide value of the region applies, Berlin €3,260 (AV Wohnen: €543.40 for two people), otherwise the municipality's rent level: level I €2,620, III €3,310, V €4,080, VI €4,470, VII €4,920. Where a federal measure works only in tight markets (rent brake areas), level VI applies, rounded to €4,500. The upper end of €5,400 is the Berlin guide value for single people. Three levels (Julian, 17 and 19 September 2026): (1) this anchor prices only the basic need, and only for people who would otherwise stay without adequate housing: the end of the moving chain (setting 30 percent, range 15 to 60 percent; for subsidised housing with occupancy rules 60 percent, range 40 to 80 percent), the displaced, and those searching with no way out. (2) What a flat is worth to the person moving in (space, location, comfort) is measured by the regional market price; it runs as an ordinary real item through face value with the consumption weight (V 5), not through this anchor, and cancels out against the costs when building. (3) Where the threat is not merely worse accommodation but homelessness, the separate homelessness anchor applies. For building on the open market the booking rule wohnbau-kosten/1.0 still applies: the market price is benefit and cost at once, and the flat itself nets to zero; additional housing is a gain exactly to the extent that it reaches people who would otherwise not be adequately housed. Counts for every year the flat is missing: a prevented flat until the end of the horizon, a delayed one only for the years of delay. Floor space on the building and cost side: target 45 m² for one person (range 35 to 50; 50 m² is the Berlin upper limit), 60 m² for two (upper limit 65), children at half.

Approach ≠ source value €619 × 12 ÷ 2 = €3,714 per person and year. Two people per household: I €437 · II €493 · III €551 · IV €619 · V €680 · VI €745 · VII €820. Berlin: guide values of the AV Wohnen (circular Soz no. 03/2023, carried forward unchanged on 1 January 2026): €449.00 for one person (50 m²), €543.40 for two (65 m²), €752.40 for four (90 m²); calculated at €6.59 per m² net rent excluding heating plus €1.77 for other running costs: https://sozialrecht.berlin.de/kategorie/rundschreiben/rs-soz-03-2023-1370812.html

Count once: rent is the payment for the flat, not its value. It runs as a pair of money items (tenant and landlord) or not at all, never in addition. The basic need stands as a SEPARATE ARGUMENT (V 6) next to the market value of the flat (face value, V 5): the market price measures the willingness to pay of whoever moves in; what it is worth that someone at the end of the moving chain is adequately housed who otherwise would not be is not in it. That is society's willingness to pay, and it is written in social law. COST SIDE REQUIRED when building (booking rule wohnbau-kosten/1.0): providing housing costs `purchase price × (interest − real appreciation) + €15 maintenance`. Where no flat is lost or added but an existing one changes use, there is no cost side; then the basic need of those at the end of the chain stands in full. w = 1 and c = 1: vulnerability is carried by V. LOSS OF COMFORT IN THE MOVING CHAIN is not booked across the board (Julian, 19 September 2026): only where a measure forces people under outside pressure into worse flats does that stand as a separate con argument with V 5, with the rent saved as money against it, checked case by case in each debate. ACCESS AND FIT remain a separate argument (shorter search, commuting avoided) with their own anchors.

Change history 5 entries
  1. since 19 September 2026 €3,700 current

    Julian's decision of 17 and 19 September 2026: the contradiction of €6,000 against €4,025 is resolved not by aligning but by separating. The old value mixed two goods, the basic need and the wish for more comfort. New: three levels. The anchor now prices only the basic need, derived from the adequacy limits of social law and graded by region (housing benefit rent levels, Berlin AV Wohnen €3,260); the value of the flat to the person moving in runs at the regional market price through face value with V 5; avoided homelessness gets its own anchor. The cost formula (€4,000/m² × 2.5 percent + €15) belongs to the booking rule wohnbau-kosten/1.0, no longer to the derivation of this value. Affected: 16 current evaluations, all given new versions.

    scoring/1.3

  2. since 16 September 2026 €6,000

    Value unchanged, contradiction documented: with the second version the user cost fell from 4.0 to 2.5 percent (after deducting expected real appreciation of 1.5 percent), but the anchor value of €6,000 stayed on the calculation at 4.0 percent. Today's formula gives €4,025. Aligning the two is a setting Julian has to make; it would affect 16 current evaluations (including bau-turbo-246e, mietpreisbremse-durchsetzung and -verschaerfung, verstaatlichungsverbot-wohnen and nine Berlin election records) and could shift categories. Until then €6,000 continues to apply.

    scoring/1.3

  3. since 16 September 2026 €6,000

    Second version on the same day: Julian sets benefit and cost equal. For ordinary building on the open market the market price is the benefit, with the same floor space on both sides; the anchor value of €6,000 still describes the low-cost sector (€4,000/m², 2.5 percent user cost, 35 m²). New: real appreciation (1.5 percent) reduces the capital cost, and the interest rate also applies to publicly financed building.

    scoring/1.3

  4. since 16 September 2026 €6,000

    Value unchanged, new justification: Julian's decision of 15 and 16 September 2026 to measure the benefit by the costs of the cheapest third. About €4,000 per m² (empirica Q4/2025: cheapest districts €3,674 to €4,305) × 4.0 percent mortgage rate (September 2026: 3.8 to 4.3 percent fixed for ten years) + €15 maintenance = €175 per m² and year; at 35 m² per person €6,100. At the same time the cost side becomes mandatory (booking rule wohnbau-kosten/1.0).

    scoring/1.3

  5. since 5 September 2026 €6,000

    Newly added while adding calculations in the housing area: four records valued the missing or additional flat at between €1,500 and €20,000 a year, unwired without an anchor and incompatible with each other. Julian's decision of 5 September 2026: access to housing as a basic right, high and oriented to rents, about €500 per person and month.

    scoring/1.3

Homelessness

per person-year in homelessness

€12,700 Germany only

What a year of homelessness weighs per person: the accommodation the public then pays for, a real resource and more expensive than any flat, and the adequate housing the person lacks during that time. The value is three times the basic need, because preventing is cheaper than bringing people back: one-off emergency aid cuts entry into shelters by three quarters.

Range €9,800 – €22,900

€12,700 per person and year as the rule: about €9,000 for accommodation (Berlin 2023 about €770 per bed and month; nationwide over €20 a day) plus the lost basic need of €3,700. Regional: Berlin €12,500 (€9,240 + €3,260); lower end €9,800 (€20 a day, rent level I), upper end €22,900 (Munich €1,500 per bed and month, rent level VII). Only for the acute case (eviction, rent arrears, release without follow-on housing, people searching from shelters): people who would become or stay homeless without the measure. The quantity is `cases × persons × duration`: whoever has lost their home finds it hard to get back, so an avoided case counts with the expected duration of homelessness, setting 2 years, range 1 to 4, as a separate step in the calculation until a German longitudinal measurement replaces it. Where a forced move leads to homelessness for only some, the share is a separate step (for orientation: an eviction judgment raises the probability of a shelter stay in the first year by 3.4 percentage points, more than three times the baseline; setting 5 percent, range 2 to 10 percent). V 8 (subsistence).

Approach ≠ source value More than 300 percent of the baseline; in addition lasting housing instability, more emergency room visits, more mental illness, and only moderate income losses. Prevention: Evans, Sullivan and Wallskog (Science 353, 2016): emergency aid of up to $1,500 cuts entry into shelters by 76 percent, $10,300 per avoided case, with benefits above that: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27516600/. Accommodation costs: Berlin 2023 about €770 per bed and month, Munich €1,500; Berlin most recently spent about €365 million a year on accommodation.

Count once: homelessness REPLACES the basic-need anchor for the same person-years, never both. Health effects (mortality, mental illness) are NOT included in the value and, where documented, go as a separate item through the life-year anchor. Accommodation costs are a real item borne by the public sector (w 1), not a transfer. US findings carry the direction and the order of magnitude, not the German quantity: share and duration stand as settings with a range in the calculation, and P stays tied to the evidence for the measure in question.

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 19 September 2026 €12,700 current

    New (Julian, 19 September 2026): an acute intervention that keeps someone from sliding into homelessness is worth considerably more than the ongoing basic need, because it is hard to get people out again. The value arises without a surcharge from the chain itself: avoided case × duration × (accommodation + lost basic need). Replaces the former upper end of the housing anchor (€12,000, the price of emergency accommodation).

    scoring/1.3

Money

Face value as the carrier. An amount of money is never the effect in itself: only the transaction class and who bears it turn it into an impact.

Euro at face value

per €

€1 applies everywhere

The reference point against which everything else is measured. One euro counts one euro, but only for flows that stay entirely within the public sector.

Source Unit of account of the scale: a setting, no external source

As soon as a money flow touches private households, face value no longer applies: the flow then goes through the income weight w. 91 percent of all scored arguments are money flows, so the weighting layer below decides more about the results than any physical anchor.

211 arguments use this anchor, in 43 proposals · 102 of them checked

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 4 July 2026 €1 current

    Unit of account, unchanged since the first registry.

    grundanker/1.2

Lifetime earnings

per working life of one person (age 20 to 60)

€1.50 million Germany only

What a person in Germany earns on average over their working life, gross, with everything that goes with it: part-time work, unemployment, years without paid work. The value is needed where a measure changes later earnings: better skills, a qualification, an earlier start in work.

No rangeNo range. One average for everyone: it does not distinguish between men and women, east and west, mothers and non-mothers, because whoever evaluates a measure should not decide whose work counts more. Applies to Germany; it is not defined for other countries.

Approach ≠ source value Men west €1.5 million, women west €0.83 million, men east €1.1 million, women east €0.66 million (age 20 to 60, 2015 prices). Weighted €1.11 million; updated with wage growth 2015 to 2025 (about +35 percent) €1.50 million, with consumer prices (about +29 percent) €1.43 million. Cross-check: 40 unbroken years at the 2025 full-time median (€54,066, Destatis) would give €2.16 million, the upper limit, not the average.

NOT A VALUE OF LIFE. This anchor measures the work output of a working life, real money. What a life weighs is in the life-year anchor and is the same for every person, including someone who never works. The two are never set against each other and never derived from each other. No discounting: one euro of extra earnings in thirty years counts like one euro today; it is cut only where it is documented that an effect does not last (booking rule bildungsertrag/1.0). Extra earnings are value added at face value, weight 1.

1 argument uses this anchor, in 1 proposal · not yet checked

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 20 September 2026 €1.50 million current

    Newly added (Julian, 20 September 2026: oriented to average earnings, one average without distinction by sex, region or parenthood). The stock set lifetime earnings per record at between €0.4 and €2.011 million. The list of missing anchors gave €1.54 million as the German value; in fact that was the median wage of Saxony-Anhalt × 40. Rejected: full-time median × 40 years (€2.16 million), because nobody on average works full time for forty unbroken years.

    scoring/1.3

Skills advantage

per one standard deviation of skills per person, lasting

€352,500 Germany only

What it is worth in later earnings when a person can permanently calculate, read and solve problems one standard deviation better. Measured on adults at work: in Germany, whoever has one standard deviation more skill earns 23.5 percent more.

No rangeNo range. The uncertainty of an education measure lies not in this rate but in the effect before it: how many children, how large an advantage, and whether it lasts. These three stand with a range in the calculation of the evaluation. One school year corresponds to about 0.3 standard deviations.

Derivation 23.5 percent higher earnings per standard deviation × €1.5 million lifetime earnings

Approach ≠ source value Full-time employees aged 35 to 54. Pooled over 23 countries 17.8 percent, USA 27.9 percent. The stock previously used 12, 17.8, 20 and 23.5 percent.

The rate applies to an advantage that lasts into working life. Whether it lasts is a question of fact: where it is documented that a school effect fades, persistence stands as a separate step in the calculation; where a measure changes the path itself (a qualification, a better start in work), it counts for the full duration (booking rule bildungsertrag/1.0). School test scores are transferred one to one to the adult scale; that is common practice, but an assumption. Scale-invariant with lifetime earnings.

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 20 September 2026 €352,500 current

    Newly added (Julian, 20 September 2026) as a derivation from lifetime earnings. The stock valued the standard deviation at between €48,000 and €533,000, a factor of 11 from return, lifetime earnings and discounting that each record set for itself. Decided at the same time: no time discounting; a cut only where a lack of persistence is documented.

    scoring/1.3

Democracy & participation

Having a say in who governs and what is decided, and that the policy that results works. There is no market for it; the values rest on a few named sources and are marked as thin.

Vote

per vote cast, prevented or devalued in an election

€1,000 applies everywhere

What it is worth to have a say in who governs, and that the policy that results works and is legitimate for everyone bound by it. What is priced is participation, not influence: that an additional vote makes the votes of others slightly lighter does not count as a loss. The value is symmetric: a newly created vote weighs as much as a prevented one. The derivation is thin, and that is stated here: there is no market for votes, only two places where someone has paid a price for one.

Range €650 – €1,000

The value depends on the level being elected, not on the topic: €1,000 in a national election (Bundestag, US federal election), €800 in a state or European election, €650 in a local election (municipal and district councils, borough councillors, mayors, district administrators). The levels follow turnout, that is, how seriously voters themselves take an election: state elections reach on average 79 percent of Bundestag turnout, the European election 78 percent, stand-alone local elections 66 percent. There is no free choice in between.

Approach ≠ source value The court found that "at least 20,000 to 30,000 votes" were affected by electoral errors and declared the election invalid. Repeating the election to the Berlin House of Representatives cost €19.8 million, €660 to €990 per affected vote. That is the price of the repair, not of casting a vote, and because of "at least" more of an upper limit. Cross-check USA: in Taylor v. Howe a federal court awarded $500 to $2,000 to each plaintiff who had been denied or obstructed in voting on racial grounds, about €800 to €3,100 today. The two sources overlap at €800 to €990.

Count once: a vote is a vote, also under 16 (wahlrechtserweiterung). A formal say in a single decision is a fraction of it (1, 2 or 10 percent, booking rule mitsprache); a referendum that is overridden devalues votes already cast. The costs of an election are money and sit on the cost side, never in the value of the vote.

14 arguments use this anchor, in 3 proposals · 12 of them checked

Change history 1 entry
  1. since 24 September 2026 €1,000 current

    Added to the Baseline (Julian, 24 September 2026). The value of €1,000 had applied since 6 September 2026 as a registry pin (conv/franchise/1.0), derived from US campaign spending × a legitimacy factor. That derivation is rejected: the cost of casting a vote is not a value, and for Germany it would have given €25 to €35. New: the repair price of the Berlin repeat election and US damages; graded by electoral level (state and European €800, local €650). No number in the permanent stock moves.

    scoring/1.3

Why some anchors need a country and others do not

Global applies everywhere

A deliberate setting, not a missing distinction: these anchors apply to every debate in every country. A life year weighs as much in Dresden as in Detroit. A change is never a one-off but a registry decision that carries every evaluation depending on it.

  • Life year
  • Statistical life
  • Serious injury
  • Minor injury
  • CO₂ equivalent
  • Nitrogen oxides
  • Person hour
  • Retirement year
  • Deprivation of liberty
  • Forced procedure
  • Euro at face value
  • Life satisfaction
  • Vote
  • Perceptibility weight c

Germany country-dependent

These quantities are not defined without a country: they depend on median income, labour costs or usage patterns that really differ between countries. A second country set adds to them; it does not replace them.

  • Working hour
  • Doctor's hour
  • Vehicle hour
  • Basic housing need
  • Homelessness
  • Lifetime earnings
  • Skills advantage
  • Income weight w

USA country-dependent

US counterparts of the country-dependent German quantities, created on 31 October 2026 (registry anker-jurisdiktion/1.1). They apply only in US records; where none exists yet, the German number may stand there at most as a declared setting with a discount.

  • Working hour (USA)
  • Income weight w (USA)

Settings for order goods

Some goods have no anchor, because no study supports a value: that rules apply, that the state can be trusted, that responsibilities are respected. Privacy can be derived from surveys and experiments; the rest stands in the calculation as a setting. This list shows each one in the English debates, 25 arguments in the current stock, live from the database, so that they can be reviewed regularly. Where the concrete damage of a rule not being enforced can be derived, it replaces the setting.

Federal room for manoeuvre 3

  • Ballots by Election Day Con · States lose the choice 24% of the balance

    × 0.50 euro Setting, range 0.10 to 2 euro: the figure used where a federal rule overrides a state legislature, applied per voter because Congress holds the last word over federal elections

  • Paying For Zoning Reform Con · Federal money in a local decision 11% of the balance

    0.20 euro-equivalent (about 23 cents) Setting, range 0.05 to 1 euro-equivalent (about 6 cents to 1.20 dollars): well below the figure used where a legislature is actually overridden, which is about two and a half times as much, because a grant competition leaves the decision where it was

  • Federal Red Flag Orders Con · States that decided otherwise 7% of the balance

    0.50 euro-equivalent (about 60 cents at 1.16 dollars to the euro) Setting, range 0.12 to 3 euro-equivalent (about 0.14 to 3.50 dollars): far below the seventy euro-equivalent this site uses where a direct popular vote is set aside, because a bill that fails in a legislature is a weaker expression of a settled choice

Fundamental rights & freedom 10

  • Companion Chatbots and Minors Con · Adults must prove who they are 32% of the balance

    Setting, range 20 to 80 million: nearly one in five American adults say they have chatted with an AI romantic companion [11], and the largest service reports 20 million monthly users worldwide [12]; 120 million would be nearly half of all American adults, so the earlier 15 and 120 million were edges rather than the middle eight in ten; the bill as reported reaches companions, not every assistant [10]

    12 minutes a year Setting, range 6 to 24 minutes a year, where the earlier 4 minutes would be a single confirmation with no re-check and 30 several failed uploads: the reported bill requires a measure tied to a real identity (verified identification, or a financial, operating-system or app-store account derived from it) and periodic re-verification of verified accounts, at an interval it does not specify [10]

    40 million × 1 euro-equivalent (about 1.20 dollars at 1.16 dollars to the euro) Setting, range 0.5 to 2.5 euro-equivalent a person (about 0.60 to 2.90 dollars): half the figure used for social media, because a chatbot conversation is private rather than published, and the earlier 0.3 and 5 euro-equivalent were the edges of what is conceivable

  • Federal Red Flag Orders Con · Owning under a condition 11% of the balance

    2 euro-equivalent (about 2.30 dollars at 1.16 dollars to the euro) Setting, range 0.5 to 8 euro-equivalent (about 0.60 to 9 dollars): the band this site uses for a restriction that reaches a large population and bites lightly

  • The Detention Buildout Con · Forty-five thousand more people held 11% of the balance

    85,000 against roughly 40,000 Setting, range 25,000 to 60,000: the plan runs toward 100,000 beds and 65,765 were held in July 2026

  • End NFA Registration Pro · Owning without a federal file 9% of the balance

    6.14 million registered silencers in May 2026 plus other items, several per owner Setting, range 2.7 to 6 million owners

    2 euro-equivalent (about 2.30 dollars) Setting, range 0.5 to 8 euro-equivalent (about 0.58 to 9.30 dollars): the band this site uses for a broad restriction that bites lightly; 1.16 dollars to the euro

  • The Forced-Labour Tariffs Pro · Forced labour that leaves the supply chain 6% of the balance

    of 23.7 million in privately imposed forced labour, out of 27.6 million in forced labour worldwide Setting, range 2 to 6 million: most forced labour is in domestic service, construction and agriculture for local markets

    5 % Setting, range 0.5 to 20 percent: the discount is 2.5 percentage points against a duty of 10 or 12.5, it applies to a country's laws rather than to any shipment, and a trade-agreement commitment or a partial regime earns it before a full ban is enforced

  • Universal Background Checks Con · Handing a gun to a friend 4% of the balance

    2 euro-equivalent (about 2.30 dollars) Setting, range 0.5 to 8 euro-equivalent (about 0.60 to 9.30 dollars at 1 euro = 1.16 dollars): the band this site uses for a restriction that applies broadly and bites lightly, since transfers within the family, at a range and for hunting are exempt

  • Federal Red Flag Orders Con · Disarmed before the hearing 4% of the balance

    3,000 euro-equivalent (about 3,500 dollars at 1.16 dollars to the euro) Setting: this site's band for an unfounded suspicion recorded against a named person, 1,000 to 20,000 euro-equivalent a case (about 1,200 to 23,000 dollars), applied to every respondent because the interim period applies to all of them; averaged over all respondents the range is 1,000 to about 7,750 euro-equivalent (about 1,200 to 9,000 dollars), with up to a third of interim orders unconfirmed at the top of the band; it carries the record and the proceedings, not a price per day, so the 72-hour hearing does not scale it down

  • A Minimum Age Online Con · Some people must prove who they are 3% of the balance

    10 % Setting, range 2 to 40 percent: the bill requires no check and no new data [6]; what is counted is platforms hedging a knowledge-fairly-implied standard — flagged adults, changed devices, platforms that decide to check everyone [10]

    12 minutes a check Setting, range 4 to 30 minutes: uploading a document, waiting, retrying when a face scan fails

    15 million identified on average × 2 euro-equivalent (about 2.30 dollars at 1.16 dollars to the euro) Setting, range 0.5 to 10 euro-equivalent a person a year (about 0.60 to 12 dollars): the identified group grows from 5 to 25 million over the horizon; the order of magnitude surveys of willingness to pay for privacy return, set here rather than found

  • Universal Background Checks Con · Checks that stop the wrong people 0% of the balance

    5,000 euro-equivalent (about 5,800 dollars) Setting, range 1,000 to 20,000 euro-equivalent (about 1,200 to 23,000 dollars at 1 euro = 1.16 dollars): this site's band for an unfounded suspicion recorded against a named person

  • The Detention Buildout Con · People removed in error 0% of the balance

    0.5 × 2 years + 0.6 × 0.22 × 2 years + 0.1 × 0.33 = 1.30 Setting: a year in the wrong country at half the rate for a year without liberty, two years on average (range half a year to five), and this includes the protection a court had granted; separation from partner and children at the rate for family separation; four months in a foreign prison for one in ten at the rate for a year without liberty

Free formation of opinion 2

  • Close the Event-Contract Gap Con · The forecasts go with the volume 23% of the balance

    350 million euro-equivalent a year Setting, range 50 million to 1 billion: the low end treats them as a curiosity that polling already supplies, the high end as a superior instrument whose accuracy is documented

  • A Minimum Age Online Con · Small sites close rather than comply 1% of the balance

    Setting, range 6 to 150 million euro-equivalent if boards close at all, whether they do being a question of plausibility; the top is the British closures scaled as if the duties were alike. British boards closed under a regime with risk assessments, complaint systems and age assurance [8]; this bill imposes none of those, requires no checks, and covers only ad-funded services with a community forum [6] — what remains is an unpriceable federal liability for volunteer operators

Law enforcement 1

  • OPT Work Permit Fee Pro · Fewer students working for sham employers 0% of the balance

    × 0.8 Setting, range 0.6 to 1.0: a sham arrangement has less reason to pay 70,000 dollars than a real job offer

    × 0.7 Setting, range 0.6 to 0.8, the same as in every argument here

    × 2,000 euro a year Setting, range 500 to 5,000 euro: no price exists for a permit used against its conditions; range 0.002 to 0.04 billion euro

Trust in the system 6

  • Ballots by Election Day Pro · Confidence in the count 10% of the balance

    × 0.15 Setting, range 0.05 to 0.30: well below the 59 percent who state distrust, because confidence follows party and the rule lowers it for others

    × 1 euro Setting, range 0.50 to 2 euro, the low end of this site's figures for thinly spread approval

  • Keep the Tips Deduction Con · Two people on the same wage, two tax bills 5% of the balance

    about 6 million for tips and 21 million for overtime, some claiming both Setting, range 20 to 28 million: claims of the first filing season; the overlap is not published

    150 euro-equivalent a year each Setting without a study, range 50 to 400: the lower end treats it as an irritation, the upper end as an erosion in the willingness to comply with a system believed to be arbitrary

  • The Repayment Overhaul Pro · A balance that stops growing 1% of the balance

    about 85 % Setting, range 1 to 8 million in all: three quarters of new enrolments saw balances rise before any waiver existed, and the older plans close by July 2028

    0.005 Setting, range 0.001 to 0.02: under two days of good health, a low reading of what borrowers describe as the most demoralising feature of the system

  • A Fully Refundable Credit Con · Money that reaches the wrong households 1% of the balance

    30 % Setting, range 10 to 60 percent: most of the money reaches households of similar income, so the dollar is worth about what it would have been; what is lost is the program's defensibility

  • SAVE America Act Pro · Confidence in the result 1% of the balance

    valued as a whole Setting, range 4 to 25 million: 71 percent support the act, 54 to 46 once the cost to eligible voters is named, so most of the gain on one side is lost on the other

  • Lifting the Payroll Cap Con · A contribution that buys nothing 0% of the balance

    3 euro-equivalent (about 3.50 dollars) Setting, range 1 to 10 euro-equivalent (about 1 to 12 dollars): the band this site uses for a broad and lightly felt change in a public arrangement, with no anchor behind it

Constitution & rule of law 3

  • National Popular Vote Pro · Close elections become far less fragile 8% of the balance

    × 90 % Setting, range 70 to 95 %: a minute national margin brings fifty recounts at once with no federal mechanism to resolve them

  • Ballots by Election Day Pro · No ballots filled in after the polls close 0% of the balance

    × 0.05 Setting, range 0.02 to 0.10: Kansas 104 against 2,110 in 2024; Nevada 24 after its primaries

    × 0.01 Setting, range 0.003 to 0.03: no documented case

  • SAVE America Act Pro · Ineligible registrations and votes are prevented 0% of the balance

    a few hundred Setting, range 200 to 5,000: Georgia's 20 per 8.2 million registrants gives about 515 non-citizens on a roll of 211 million, nine in twenty of them had voted; Kansas found 39 in nineteen years; mandatory matching adds removals

44 further arguments in the German debates carry such a setting; they are listed on the German version of this page (switch to “DE” at the top).

The rule behind it (ordnungsgut/1.0)

(1) PRIVACY is derived from studies: willingness to pay = compensation demanded ÷ 5.5 (Acquisti, John and Loewenstein 2013, field experiment). Germans ask €4.51 a month for handing over their fingerprint and €1.99 for their location (Prince and Wallsten 2020). This is multiplied by a narrowing factor for a narrower object (only data that is public anyway, only with a court order: ⅓ to ⅒), plus the expected damage from misuse (detected unauthorised police queries of 2 to 3.5 per million inhabitants a year, false match rates according to NIST; both cent amounts per person). Access with a judicial warrant weighs less than access without one (PACT survey, EU). Guide value for biometric searchability of public images: €2, range €1 to €3.50 per person and year. (2) RULES BEING IN FORCE, TRUST, ENFORCEMENT: no study supports a per-head value. What is valued is therefore the CONCRETE DAMAGE that arises when the rule does not apply or is not enforced (consequential damage, offences, costs), with a source, never a price "per enforced order" or "for the rule holding". Where no damage can be derived, a per-head value remains as a DECLARED SETTING: lower bound 0 for pure signals, reference group named (for signals only those who expect it), the rate marked in the calculation as a "setting without a study", P not above the cap of the evidence ladder. (3) FEELING OF SAFETY: fear of crime 0.00065 healthy life years per person and year (Dolan and Peasgood, cited only via the Home Office 2018, not checked in the original); use only with this note. (4) TRANSPARENCY: every setting of this kind appears automatically on the Baseline page in the section "Settings for order goods" (arguments with one of the values named and a setting step in the calculation), with value, reasoning and record, so that they can be reviewed regularly.

How far the Baseline is wired into the stock

An anchor is only as useful as the information on which evaluations depend on it. These numbers come live from the database, not from an export, and cover the English debates. They show what a recalibration would actually move.

267 of 417 arguments carry a derivation that can be recalculated · 64.0%

The rest is calculated correctly, but there the calculation stands only as running text in the impact justification and cannot be checked by machine. That is being caught up.

Ask the bot

The bot explains the method and the debate on this page. It answers only from Argupedia's content and does no research of its own.

Before you ask

  • The answers are written by an AI model (Claude Haiku by Anthropic). They may be wrong or incomplete. The content of the pages is authoritative.
  • The bot gives no legal, financial, medical or voting advice.
  • What you type is sent to Anthropic in the USA. Do not enter names, contact details or other personal information.

The terms of use (section 9a) and the privacy notice for the chat apply.