The value catalogue

Two arguments can move the same amount and still not carry the same weight: 500 million in budget costs is not the same as 500 million in deaths avoided. The value weight V is where that difference is recorded. This page sets out which values the catalogue knows, which class each one sits in and with what weight that class enters the score.

36 values · as of 12 November 2026 · bound to scoring/1.3 · scale 0–10 in steps of 0.5, class anchors 3–10

V follows the effect, never the topic

This is the one rule from which everything else follows. The weight does not go to the debate but to the specific effect an argument claims. An argument in a health debate that prices administrative costs is a cost argument and sits in the Money class, not in Life & health just because that is the topic. Conversely, a transport argument about road deaths carries the full weight of life, even though the debate is about speed limits.

Two applications of the same rule are recorded as settings in the registry. An argument that prices costs sits in the Money class, even if the money is spent on saving lives. And money lost by low-income households remains money: it weighs more through the income weighting that the baseline sets, but it does not move into the Subsistence class, because the same hardship would otherwise be counted twice.

  1. 1

    Name the effect

    What exactly does the argument move? Not the topic: the effect.

    1.4 million t CO₂ less per year

  2. → catalogue
  3. 2

    Choose the value

    The best-fitting entry in the catalogue below. For a genuinely mixed good, several, with the dominant one first.

    Climate

  4. → class
  5. 3

    The class anchor

    Every value sits in exactly one value class, and every class sets an anchor.

    Participation & environment → V 7

  6. ± 1.0
  7. 4

    Value weight V

    Within ±1.0 of the anchor, a reasoned deviation is allowed. No further: that is what another class is for.

    V 7

The example is real: it is the CO₂ argument of the measure “Tempolimit 130” (a 130 km/h motorway speed limit, a debate on the German side of Argupedia), the same argument that the baseline uses to show its quantity calculation.

The ladder

Eight classes between 3 and 10. The scale is linear, unlike the conversion anchors, which span six powers of ten. That is deliberate: V is not meant to repeat orders of magnitude, which are already in the impact. V only says how much one unit of this good weighs.

Life & health 4 values
V 10
Constitutional core 4 values
V 9
Subsistence & education 2 values
V 8
Participation & environment 9 values
V 7
Systems & prosperity 7 values
V 6
Money 4 values
V 5
Utility & comfort 5 values
V 4
Marginal utility 1 value
V 3
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

class anchor permitted range ±1.0

The bands overlap: there is no gap between two neighbouring classes. For a mixed value (deaths and injuries, costs and time saved), V lies between the anchors of the classes involved, closer to the good that dominates the impact. The catalogue explicitly allows such mixtures; the reasoning has to support them. At the top, the range ends at the end of the scale: nothing goes above V 10, not even with a premium.

Below the ladder there is still 0, and it is not a very small importance but exclusion: where V = 0, the argument drops out of the evaluation, its score is 0 and the reason is stored with it. The same rule applies to plausibility and impact: a zero on any of the three axes ends the calculation rather than shrinking it.

Every value in turn

The catalogue grows with the stock: if no entry fits an effect, a new one is created instead of stretching the closest one. Existing entries are never recycled: an evaluation made yesterday has to price the same thing tomorrow. The related values listed under each entry record what belongs together.

Life & health V 10

Physical integrity: deaths, life years, lasting harm. The top of the scale.

Life

V 10

Lives and life years lost or saved: statistical lives, road deaths, excess mortality, additional deaths from treatment that is withheld or delayed.

27 arguments price this value, in 20 measures · V 5.0–10.0 · 23 of them dominant

Protection from crime

V 10

Victims of crime avoided (or added): the physical and mental integrity of third parties. The fiscal share for justice and enforcement belongs to Public finances or Enforcement & procedure.

5 arguments price this value, in 4 measures · V 8.0–9.5 · 1 of them dominant

Lifetime

V 10

Time lived that a measure takes from people or gives them (travel time, waiting time, hours tied up), derived from the life-year anchor. The same good as life and health, one step below: divisible, recoverable, often self-chosen. The quality of the hour lies in the anchor factor (30 percent of an hour in a car counts as lost), never here; Lifetime carries no weighting for how noticeable it is.

12 arguments price this value, in 11 measures · V 9.0 · 10 of them dominant

Constitutional core V 9

What carries the order itself: fundamental rights, the rule of law, the right to vote, external security.

Right to vote & vote weight

V 9

Access to elections and the weight of each vote: who may vote, who is actually able to vote and how much a vote cast counts in the result. The measures are votes prevented or enabled and vote-weight equivalents. The high weight follows from the fact that taking part in decisions is self-determination: whoever votes helps shape the rules they live under.

11 arguments price this value, in 3 measures · V 9.0 · dominant throughout

External security

V 9

Protecting the existence of the state, its territorial integrity and the collective self-determination of the community against military attack; defence capability and credible deterrence as the carriers of this good.

Not yet used by any argument in the English-language stock.

Subsistence & education V 8

The floor of a life, and the access needed to rise above it.

Educational opportunity

V 8

Skills, qualifications and chances of advancement as the threshold to an independent living: basic skills, access to vocational training, lifetime earnings through the education channel.

13 arguments price this value, in 8 measures · V 8.0 · dominant throughout

Participation & environment V 7

Goods that belong to many and that nobody can buy back on their own.

Climate

V 7

Climate effects, valued at the abatement cost per tonne of CO₂ equivalent: the anchor set by the baseline, as a fixed rate without staggering by year of emission.

10 arguments price this value, in 6 measures · V 7.0 · dominant throughout

Environment & nature

V 7

Local and diffuse environmental goods: biodiversity, air quality, noise, soils, land, groundwater; often irreversible and spanning generations.

Related Climate, Health

6 arguments price this value, in 5 measures · V 5.0–7.0 · 4 of them dominant

Equal treatment

V 7

Equal treatment of people in the same position: what is priced is an extra burden or an advantage that cannot be justified against a named standard (the equality principle, even-handed taxation, the equivalence principle). How hard a euro hits an income group is carried by the income weight of the money argument, not here.

1 argument prices this value, in 1 measure · V 7.0 · dominant throughout

Fairness between generations

V 7

Fairness in how burdens are shared between age cohorts, above all in the pay-as-you-go system: the basis of legitimacy for the contract between generations, measured by contribution burden, wealth and future entitlements.

Not yet used by any argument in the English-language stock.

Life planning & family

V 7

Realising central, time-bound life decisions, above all starting a family and the wish for children. What is valued is the unfulfilled life plan of those affected: heavier than money, below health and subsistence.

Related Job security

1 argument prices this value, in 1 measure · V 7.0 · dominant throughout

Working conditions

V 7

The quality of work beyond pay and job security: workload and staffing ratios, working hours, collective agreements as a set of rules, chances of advancement and training at work.

1 argument prices this value, in 1 measure · V 7.0 · dominant throughout

Systems & prosperity V 6

The working order of institutions, markets and public services.

Prosperity & output

V 6

Economy-wide value creation, growth, employment and the investment base: the euro that never comes into being (rather than one merely shifted), from which every other service is paid.

35 arguments price this value, in 20 measures · V 5.0–6.0 · dominant throughout

Competitive order

V 6

The fairness and functioning of market competition: a level playing field, open market access, the order in which the more efficient offer wins. Affected when state intervention shifts market shares regardless of performance.

1 argument prices this value, in 1 measure · V 6.0 · dominant throughout

Federal room for manoeuvre

V 6

The ability of the federal states and other levels to set rules that differ by region and to try out policy: a property of the political system whose loss takes effect over decades, below the threshold of the constitutional core.

5 arguments price this value, in 5 measures · V 6.0 · dominant throughout

Housing supply

V 6

The availability and fit of housing: the supply base of the housing market (building, renovating, densifying) as well as the fit between household and home. Structurally above comfort and budget flows; it only tips towards subsistence when homelessness threatens.

4 arguments price this value, in 3 measures · V 5.0–6.0 · 3 of them dominant

Quality of administration

V 6

How well public action is steered and carried out: length of procedures and legal certainty, how well spending hits its target, the quality and effectiveness of rule-making and programme management.

4 arguments price this value, in 3 measures · V 6.0 · dominant throughout

Law enforcement

V 6

The enforcement of existing law as a system good: the ability of authorities to enforce, the inspection and punishment of breaches, the credibility of the rule; independent of what the rule says and of the resources spent.

2 arguments price this value, in 2 measures · V 6.0 · dominant throughout

Money V 5

Money as money: the fixed point of the scale. Every cost argument sits here.

Public finances

V 5

Public budgets at face value: tax revenue and revenue losses, subsidies, programme and opportunity costs of the federal government, the states, local authorities and social insurance funds.

68 arguments price this value, in 33 measures · V 5.0–5.5 · 62 of them dominant

Enforcement & procedure

V 5

Real resources tied up in administration, inspection, documentation and litigation: the working time of authorities, courts, insurance funds, firms and citizens, and capital tied up while procedures last. Priced at face value; carriers both public and private.

21 arguments price this value, in 19 measures · V 5.0 · dominant throughout

Utility & comfort V 4

Convenience, minutes saved, experience value. Real, but secondary.

Time & comfort

V 4

Convenience, predictability and everyday usefulness without any effect on income, health or participation. Pure amounts of time (travel time, waiting time) have counted as Lifetime since September 2026; what remains here is the comfort of one solution over another.

Not yet used by any argument in the English-language stock.

Everyday autonomy

V 4

Running one's daily life by one's own choices and spending one's own budget freely (where to shop, paying in cash, buying second-hand): more than convenience, below an interference with fundamental rights; weighted up for groups with no budget to fall back on.

3 arguments price this value, in 3 measures · V 4.0–5.0 · dominant throughout

Experience & preferences

V 4

The hedonic benefit of freely chosen activities and preferences, such as the pleasure of driving or the value of a hobby, beyond pure time saved; a preference chosen freely, not a basic need.

2 arguments price this value, in 2 measures · V 4.0 · dominant throughout

Pension security

V 4

The reliability of a pension promise above the subsistence threshold: how predictable the promised entitlement is, regardless of its amount. Measures: guaranteed versus risk-bearing replacement rate, the range over which the entitlement can vary.

1 argument prices this value, in 1 measure · V 4.0 · dominant throughout

Income without return

V 4

Money someone receives without providing a matching service in return, above all the income of gambling and betting operators from players' losses. The money flow counts in full (weight 1), but the value of receiving it lies below Money: standard value V 3.

6 arguments price this value, in 4 measures · V 1.0–2.0 · dominant throughout

Marginal utility V 3

The bottom of the scale: effects counted because they exist, not because they carry weight.

Freely chosen spending

V 3

Money someone spends voluntarily on something they want: fuel for higher speed, consumption, gambling. If the spending is avoided by compulsion, the amount is not already the gain: something was bought that falls away too, and whoever bought it valued it more than the money. The remainder counts at the bottom of the scale. Distinct from money that has to be spent.

Not yet used by any argument in the English-language stock.

What belongs together

Values are not independent of each other. Pricing life touches on health; pricing climate touches on environment and nature. These relations are recorded in the catalogue in both directions, each with a sentence of reasoning, so that an evaluation notices when the same effect is counted twice.

How the stock uses the catalogue

A catalogue nobody uses says nothing. These figures come live from the database: they show which values carry the stock and which entries have not been used so far. The count covers the whole English-language stock, each debate in its latest version. The German-language stock is counted on the German version of this page (switch to “DE” at the top).

All 417 arguments carry a value assignment; the schema lets none through without one.

The 12 most used of the 32 values that occur in the stock. The other 20 show their figures on their own cards above.

Not yet used by any argument: External security, Fairness between generations, Time & comfort, Freely chosen spending. That is not an error: the catalogue may run ahead of the stock, as long as no entry is stretched to fill a gap.

Ask the bot

The bot explains the method and the debate on this page. It answers only from Argupedia's content and does no research of its own.

Before you ask

  • The answers are written by an AI model (Claude Haiku by Anthropic). They may be wrong or incomplete. The content of the pages is authoritative.
  • The bot gives no legal, financial, medical or voting advice.
  • What you type is sent to Anthropic in the USA. Do not enter names, contact details or other personal information.

The terms of use (section 9a) and the privacy notice for the chat apply.