Fee money for the Treasury
Every OPT recommendation that still goes ahead brings 70,000 dollars into the Treasury, and every extension 30,000 more. Even if most students stop using the permit, those who remain would pay about 3.7 billion dollars a year. The same money leaves colleges, students and employers, which is the first argument against.
▸ Show reasoning & sources ▾ Hide reasoning & sources
Value
The stream is public revenue, priced at the middle of the scale like any other dollar. The agency that collects the fee does not keep it: the rule sends it to the Treasury as general receipts [1][13], so it pays for nothing in particular and is valued as general public money. Whether a payment of this kind is a gain or a loss depends on where it comes from and where it goes, and that difference is booked in the Impact of the pair rather than here. Its counterpart, the same amount paid by colleges and passed on to students and employers, is the first argument against. The value is the middle of the scale, the level this site uses for public money whatever it is spent on.
Impact
The rule charges 70,000 dollars for a first OPT recommendation and 30,000 dollars for each later one, including the 24-month extension for science and engineering graduates [1]. About 150,000 first recommendations a year are taken as the starting point, between the 108,000 graduates a year that one model counts and the 194,554 permits granted in 2024 [1][3]. International enrolment is already falling, so 85 percent of that is used for the years ahead [5][7]. Of those, 40 percent are assumed still to go ahead at the new price, the mirror of the fall in use in the arguments against [4]; that is 51,000 a year. Each brings 70,000 dollars plus 30,000 more for the 42.5 percent who later take the extension, 82,750 dollars on average, or 4.2 billion dollars a year. The first year counts half because the rule applies only 60 days after it is final, which gives 3.7 billion dollars a year over the four years. The department's own figure, which assumes almost no fall in use, is 8.4 to 16.5 billion dollars a year [2]. The range here runs from 1.2 to 8.9 billion dollars, depending above all on how many still pay. The Impact is large in money and small in welfare, because the same sum appears as a cost on the other side.
▸ Show calculation ▾ Hide calculation
Plausibility
The amount depends on one behavioural link: how many recommendations still go ahead once a college must pay before it can enter them. The counterfactual is the current programme with no fee. No fee of this size has ever been charged on a student work permit, so the number rests on estimated price responses rather than on a precedent [4]. The confounder is the fall in international enrolment that was under way before the rule, which is handled by a separate trend factor [5][7]. Reverse causation does not arise, because the fee is set by rule. That money is collected once the rule applies is not in doubt; how much is, and that doubt sits in the range. The Plausibility is just above the middle, the ceiling for a projection of a behavioural response, and the argument it is paired with carries the same figure.