Fee money for the immigration agencies
Every cap petition that still goes ahead brings 103,265 dollars to the immigration agencies. Even if a third of hiring under the cap stops, the fee would raise about 5.7 billion dollars a year. The same money leaves the employers who pay it, which is the first argument against.
▸ Show reasoning & sources ▾ Hide reasoning & sources
Value
The stream is public revenue, priced at the middle of the scale like any other dollar. The proposal sends the money to the immigration fee account and from there to immigration courts, enforcement, vetting, visa processing and labour inspection in four departments, about 8.8 billion dollars in all [1][2]. Those budgets are funded today from other receipts and appropriations, so the fee relieves the public purse rather than buying anything new in particular, and it is valued as general public money. Whether a payment of this kind is a gain or a loss depends on where it comes from and where it goes, and that difference is booked in the Impact of the pair rather than here. Its counterpart, the same amount paid by employers, is the first argument against. The value is the middle of the scale, the level this site uses for public money whatever it is spent on.
Impact
The fee is 103,265 dollars for each petition under the cap of 85,000 a year, of which 20,000 are reserved for holders of American advanced degrees [1]. The department expects all 85,000 to be filed, which gives its figure of about 8.8 billion dollars a year [1][2]. This evaluation does not follow that assumption: five analyses of a fee of this size expect demand to fall by 63 to 91 percent, four of them expect the cap to go unfilled, and after the 100,000-dollar charge on new entrants of 2025 consular H-1B filings fell by more than 90 percent while employers paid it for only about 700 people [2][3][4]. A fall of 35 percent in cap petitions actually filed is used here, in a range from 12 to 70 percent, the middle of the published estimates of cap visas no longer used. That leaves 55,250 petitions a year and 5.7 billion dollars. Every one of the four cap seasons in the horizon counts in full. The range runs from 2.7 to 7.8 billion dollars, depending on how many employers still pay. The Impact is large in money and small in welfare, because the same sum appears as a cost on the other side.
▸ Show calculation ▾ Hide calculation
Plausibility
The amount depends on one behavioural link: how many employers still file once a petition costs about thirty times what it costs now [2][3]. The counterfactual is the current weighted selection with no fee. No fee of this size has been charged on all cap petitions, so the number rests on estimated price responses and on one precedent, the 2025 charge on entries from abroad, which exempted people already in the country and so covered a narrower group [2][4]. The confounder in that precedent is that the charge arrived together with other restrictions, which may have deterred filings on their own. Reverse causation does not arise, because the fee is set by rule. That money is collected once the rule applies is not in doubt; how much is, and that doubt sits in the range. The Plausibility is just above the middle, the ceiling for a projection of a behavioural response, and the argument it is paired with carries the same figure.